Overview
Description
Gulf-to-bay on Casey Key. Wake up to golden sunrises over Blackburn Bay, spend your afternoons on your own private sandy beach and end the day surrounded by breathtaking views stretching from the Intracoastal Waterway to the turquoise waters on the Gulf. This exceptional Gulf-to-bay property offers a rare opportunity to experience the very best of waterfront living on Casey Key’s pristine eight-mile barrier island.
Impeccably maintained, the charming vintage cottage is move-in ready and filled with coastal character. The inviting floor plan features a spacious living room, two bedrooms, an office that presently serves as a third bedroom and a dining area framed by beautiful bay views. Go outside and embrace the waterfront lifestyle with a peaceful deck, private dock, pool and a 10,000-pound boat lift installed in 2022.
The property offers some of the deepest boating water in the area, making it ideal for boating, fishing, paddleboarding, kayaking and endless days on the water. Recent improvements include a new roof in 2023 and interior and exterior paint, allowing you to settle in and enjoy this special setting. For those dreaming of creating a new coastal residence, the property also presents an exceptional opportunity to build in the future while providing immediate use and enjoyment.
Beyond the property, Casey Key offers an unparalleled sense of privacy and natural beauty while remaining conveniently close to everything you need. Private air travel is available at Venice Airport (within 15 minutes) and Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport (within 40 minutes). Shopping, dining, golf and other amenities are all within easy reach.
Whether you envision preserving the charm of this beloved beach cottage or creating a spectacular new waterfront retreat, this extraordinary Gulf-to-bay property is a rare slice of paradise and an opportunity to call Casey Key home.
Address
Interior
- AppliancesDishwasher, Dryer, Exhaust Fan, Microwave, Range, Refrigerator, Washer
- Bathrooms Full2
- Bathrooms Half0
- Bathrooms Total Integer2
- Bedrooms Total3
- CoolingCentral Air, Zoned
- CoolingYes
- Fireplace FeaturesLiving Room
- FireplaceYes
- FlooringCarpet, Tile, Vinyl
- FurnishedFurnished
- HeatingElectric
- HeatingYes
- Interior FeaturesCeiling Fan(s), Living Room/Dining Room Combo, Thermostat, Walk-In Closet(s), Window Treatments
- Laundry FeaturesLaundry Closet
- LevelsOne
- Living Area1,940
- Living Area SourcePublic Records
- Living Area UnitsSquare Feet
- Rooms Total6
Exterior
- Attached GarageYes
- Carport Spaces1
- CarportYes
- Covered Spaces2
- Direction FacesWest
- Exterior FeaturesStorage
- Garage Spaces1
- GarageYes
- Lot FeaturesCoastalConstruction Control Line, FloodZone
- Lot Size Acres1
- Lot Size Area25,447
- Lot Size Square Feet25,447
- Lot Size UnitsSquare Feet
- Patio And Porch FeaturesDeck, Front Porch
- Pool FeaturesAbove Ground
- Road Frontage TypeStreet Paved
- Road Surface TypePaved
- RoofShingle
- Water Body NameBLACKBURN BAY & GULF
- Waterfront FeaturesBay/Harbor, Gulf/Ocean, Gulf/Ocean to Bay, Intracoastal Waterway
Structure
- Architectural StyleFlorida, Ranch
- Building Area Total3,188
- Construction MaterialsBlock, Stucco
- Foundation DetailsSlab
- Year Built1950
Utilities
- SewerPublic Sewer
- UtilitiesCable Connected, Electricity Connected, Water Connected
- Water SourcePublic
Financial
- Parcel Number0166130008
- Pets AllowedYes
- Tax Annual Amount31,003
- Tax Legal DescriptionCOM AT INTERSECTION OF N LINE OF SEC 27-38-18 & SHORELINE OF GULF OF MEXICO TH SELY ALG SAID SHORELINE 2786.44 FT FOR POB TH CONT SELY ALG SAID SHORELINE 100 FT TH DUE E TO SHORE OF
- Tax Lot0
- Tax Year2025
- ZoningRE2
Schools
- Elementary SchoolLaurel Nokomis Elementary
- High SchoolVenice Senior High
- Middle Or Junior SchoolLaurel Nokomis Middle
Location
- CountryUnited States
- County Or ParishSarasota
- DirectionsFrom Sarasota: Blackburn Point Rd to South on Casey Key Rd to 1604 From Venice: Albee Rd West to North on Casey Key Rd to 1604
- Latitude27
- Longitude-82
- MLS Area Major34275 - Nokomis/North Venice
- Postal Code34275
- Postal Code Plus43367
- Street NameCASEY KEY
- Street Number1604
- Street Number Numeric1,604
- Street SuffixROAD
- Subdivision NameCASEY KEY
- Unparsed Address1604 CASEY KEY ROAD
Listing Info
- List Price3,695,000
- Contract Status Change DateSeptember 18, 2026
- Cumulative Days On Market18
- Days On Market18
- Internet Consumer CommentYes
- Lease ConsideredYes
- List Agent AORSarasota - Manatee
- List Agent Emailvalerie.dallacqua@premiersir.com
- List Agent Full NameValerie Dall'Acqua
- List Agent Keyc7317b80e97be5070c646e069dad4fa0
- List Agent MLS ID456512232
- List Agent Preferred Phone941-445-7295
- List Office MLS ID281519790
- List Office NamePREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY
- List Office Phone941-364-4000
- Listing Contract DateSeptember 18, 2026
- Listing IDA4706670
- Listing Key8824e386116c397dd8d979281e2cf19a
- Listing TermsCash, Conventional
- MLS StatusActive
- Modification TimestampSeptember 21, 2026
- On Market DateSeptember 18, 2026
- Original Entry TimestampSeptember 18, 2026
- Original List Price3,695,000
- Originating System Keystellar
- Originating System NameStellar MLS
- OwnershipFee Simple
- Photos Change TimestampSeptember 18, 2026
- Photos Count61
- Source System Key811796088
- Special Listing ConditionsNone
- Status Change TimestampSeptember 18, 2026
Features & Amenities
Mortgage Calculator
- Principal & interest
- Property tax
- Home insurance
- PMI
- HOA dues
Estimates only and not a loan offer. Taxes, insurance and rates vary — confirm with a lender.
Meet your agent
Valerie Dall'Acqua
Listing Agent · PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY
Get in touch
Office · 941-364-4000
Similar Listings
Tour requested
The agent will confirm your tour time shortly.
Message sent
The agent will get back to you shortly.
